The role of JROTC in high schools has been a point of debate since its founding in 1916. It became a major point of protest during the Vietnam era with many college students who resented their school’s administrators and college trustees refusal to cut ties with military personnel. ROTC buildings across the country were trashed, burned, or set on fire- the most famous instance occurring at Kent State in May of 1970. An arson attempt on the campus’ ROTC building triggered a National Guard occupation where four students were fatally shot, leading to the biggest student strike in US history.
For students in low income homes, enrollment in the army can provide many privileges and basic needs they aren’t guaranteed access to, including a college education, a steady career, and even access to basic needs like food and shelter. According to the Council on Foreign Relations, around 64% of enlistments are made up of people with household incomes below 87,000$, and an additional 19% are from families that make less than 41,691$. Furthermore, a report by RAND corporation done in 2017 showed that 56% of schools that offer JROTC have federal funding for reduced or free lunch options, suggesting there is a significant number of students on or below the poverty line.
Many schools, including Portland Public, removed army based programs from their school due to the controversial “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy, a policy that prohibited US military members from being openly LGBTQ. Transgender individuals weren’t allowed to serve under any circumstances until 2016, and quickly lost the right under the Trump administration. This actually wasn’t because of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policies, but because of a clause in the military’s medical policy that considers individuals with Gender Identity Disorder unfit for service. While these policies only affect ROTC programs in colleges, there’s no doubt that this culture of bigotry likely trickles down to high school programs.
The military also has a long history of discrimination and abuse towards female veterans. In 2010, the Department of Defense estimated that more than 19,000 military sexual assaults took place, but that only 14% of them were reported, and that 1 in 3 military sex offenders were permitted to stay enlisted even after an investigation took place. In June of 2024, a group of senate Democrats held a press conference with the Department of Defense to discuss the rampant abuse young girls face in JROTC programs, and requested for government officials to pass a reform to ensure students are protected from sexual misconduct.
This conference likely arose from a 2022 investigation in The New York Times that found at least 33 JROTC instructors across the country had been criminally charged with sexual crimes in the last five years. This led to the House Oversight Committee launching their own investigation, revealing an additional 60 instructors that were persecuted in the same time frame. In the 2024 letters to senators concerning the issue, the Pentagon revealed they had received over 114 allegations of instructors perpetuating acts of violence, sexual abuse or sexual harassment against cadets in JROTC programs across the country.
Oregon City High School stands for equality, inclusion, and diversity, and has several policies that prohibit students and teachers from bullying or discrimination on the basis of sex, gender, race, class and orientation. But by allowing the army in our schools, through recruitment and JROTC, we go against the very values we claim are a pillar of our community. By doing so, we create an environment that not only puts students at risk of discrimination, but abuse and harassment by those in an immense position of power over them, and perpetuates an already aching disparity between students in lower class homes. And that is why it’s essential that OCHS removes military involvement from our community, so we can instead have a community truly built upon the pillars of inclusion, diversity, respect and safety.
Landen • Jan 21, 2025 at 12:15 pm
As a student in the JROTC program at oregon city high school i don’t believe this accurately shows what the program at the high school is truly like. this is my fourth year in the program and half of this article couldn’t be more far from the truth about our program. This article says the role of JROTC has been a point of debate since 1916 and became a major point of protest in the Vietnam era which was 50 years ago then goes on to list what happened at a ROTC. ROTC is a college military program and is very different from JROTC as JROTC is just high school and doesn’t mean you’re going into service. At the end of the article the author claims that the program goes against what the high school stands for but the program is very welcoming to anyone no matter their gender, race, or orientation and bullying is strictly prohibited. The class isn’t even strictly military the class itself teaches anger management, stress management and so on so fourth, it has helped many students with what there going through especially with the help of our amazing instructors. There is so much more I could say but overall I believe the author should have included perspectives from students and instructors within the program to provide a more balanced view. This article does not reflect the positive impact JROTC has had on many students myself included.
Caleb • Jan 21, 2025 at 4:50 am
This article quite resembles one sided news networks that simply promote their own views and priorities while failing to mention the opposition. Obviously, as an editorial, this is just the opinion of an outside point of view. But the only reason I’d have a problem with it, is that this author must have never been a part of the organization nor really experienced it. The JROTC program spends its time providing with an in school, and out of school, community for students who may not get that opportunity elsewhere. I spent 4 years in the program before enlisting into the US military. I can say with utmost confidence that the program is nothing like the real military. Of course there’s similarities as it’s a military based program. But the military is an entirely different lifestyle to anything within the JROTC program. The JROTC program provides opportunities to instill discipline, volunteer events for community service (including but not limited to; cleaning the local cemeteries and cleaning/renovating local parks, getting involved with the VFW and other veteran based events), physical readiness training, learning the importance of filing your taxes and how to do it, including the forms. All great things that no other class will follow into. It’s one of the schools few classes that really makes a tight connection between community and students as well as real world preparation. And that’s whether or not one decides to enlist. But there even is benefits to that too. Going into the service with at least a basic understanding of uniform standards, military doctrine, general orders, etc. And even a boost in rank.
In short, I think that, even being an opinion piece, the author should have included the benefits to the program instead of comparing it to history during the Vietnam War, essentially demonizing it.
Evan Roberts • Jan 20, 2025 at 10:26 pm
This is such an ignorant article. JROTC programs all over the nation is full of diverse groups of students who feel at home thanks to JROTC programs. The OCHS JROTC program is a huge part of many kids lives and has given them a place to feel at home. There are actually quite a few kids who are lgbtq in the JROTC program if you actually cared to check. The community that JROTC creates is one that a lot of kids need and it makes kids grow in leadership, knowledge, and confidence.